A reputation at dinner
The reply treats an unflattering reputation as proof of recognition.
Read caption text
- The criticism
- You’re that terrible cook
- The optimistic reply
- But you have heard of me
Also called But You Have Heard of Me · Worst Pirate I Have Ever Heard Of · Jack Sparrow Reputation
Norrington points out a failure, and Jack Sparrow finds a reason to count it as a win. Put the criticism above and the shamelessly optimistic reply below.
The second speaker changes the measure of success. Being known for something embarrassing becomes a victory because at least people remember it.
The joke works when the reply admits the criticism indirectly rather than disproving it. A bad presentation can still be memorable, and an unreliable app can still have users.
The exchange comes from Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl, released in 2003. During Jack Sparrow’s arrest, James Norrington dismisses his reputation as a pirate. Jack chooses to focus on the fact that Norrington has heard of him. [1] [2]
Online adaptations appeared well before the 2020s. Know Your Meme records a 2004 Harry Potter caption-contest entry borrowing the exchange and a 2011 upload arranging the film scene as two captioned panels. [2]
The Curse of the Black Pearl introduces this exchange between Norrington and Jack Sparrow. [1]
A MuggleNet caption-contest entry applies the joke to Gilderoy Lockhart. [2]
An online image pairs the two film stills with their dialogue. [2]
Put the complaint at the bottom of the upper panel, under Norrington’s face. Put the reply near the lower edge of Jack’s panel, keeping his expression and raised fingers visible.
Give the first line a genuine criticism. Then let Jack point to recognition, attention, or some other small success that the critic accidentally acknowledged.
Original captions to try with this template.
The reply treats an unflattering reputation as proof of recognition.
The presentation earns attention even if the audience disapproves of the method.
The response counts being installed as a victory without defending the crashes.
References for this template. Example captions are original.
The official film page lists its July 2003 release and cast.
Documents the original exchange and early online adaptations from 2004 and 2011.