Original artwork by Anton Gudim (lower comic)
More work, same guess
The spreadsheet makes the process look more rigorous without improving the guess.
Read caption text
- The simple approach
- Guessing
- The elaborate approach
- Guessing with a spreadsheet
Also called Jumping on a Rake · Skateboard Rake · Stepping on a Rake Comparison
One person steps on a rake; another performs an elaborate trick and lands on it anyway. Compare a simple mistake with a more impressive route to exactly the same mistake.
The lower sequence looks more skillful, but its ending is no better. That makes this a comparison between different methods that fail in the same way.
Use it for overthinking, unnecessary complexity, or experience that has not stopped a familiar error. The second caption should add effort without changing the outcome.
The lower drawing is a comic by Anton Gudim, posted through gudim_public on April 26, 2018. A figure treats a rake like a skateboard, performs a trick, and still gets hit by its handle. [1]
A July 9, 2018 post on r/ProgrammerHumor paired that comic with stock renders of a person simply stepping on a rake. New comparisons followed within days, with further versions circulating in 2019 and 2020. [1]
The elaborate trick ends with the familiar handle-to-face gag. [1]
A Reddit post compares the stock-image accident with Gudim’s more elaborate sequence. [1]
Edits and a blank template spread through Reddit, Twitter, and Imgur. [1]
Label the simple approach in the white space below the top sequence. Label the elaborate approach on the open ground in the lower comic.
Use two versions of the same activity. The lower caption should sound more complicated or confident, while the pictures show that the result stays the same.
Original captions to try with this template.
Original artwork by Anton Gudim (lower comic)
The spreadsheet makes the process look more rigorous without improving the guess.
Original artwork by Anton Gudim (lower comic)
The extra restructuring still ends with broken code.
Original artwork by Anton Gudim (lower comic)
Making the bread from scratch adds effort without preventing the same burnt result.
References for this template. Example captions are original.
Credits Gudim’s comic and documents the July 2018 combination with stock renders.