The late-night mystery
Staying awake is treated as unrelated to the next morning’s exhaustion.
Read caption text
- Who or what causes the problem
- Me at 2 a.m.
- What suffers
- My sleep
- The baffled question
- Why am I tired?
Also called Why Would X Do This · Eric Andre Shooting Hannibal · Eric Andre Blames Someone Else
Eric André causes a problem, then turns to the camera as if someone else must be responsible. Label the person making the bad decision, what suffers, and the excuse that ignores the obvious cause.
The audience has just seen who caused the damage. The question in the second picture is funny because it pretends that the answer is a mystery.
Use it for a habit you refuse to blame, an avoidable consequence, or a misplaced accusation. The first picture needs to establish the cause clearly enough for the second picture to contradict it.
The scene comes from season two, episode six of The Eric Andre Show, which aired on November 7, 2013. During the sketch, André shoots co-host Hannibal Buress and then asks who killed him. The question turns something the audience just witnessed into a mock mystery. [1]
Two screenshots became an object-labeling format in April 2018. Versions replace the spoken question with an accusation against somebody else, or with confusion about a problem the speaker plainly caused. The familiar “Why would X do this?” wording is a meme variation on the scene. [2] [1]
Put the responsible person or behavior on André’s jacket in the upper picture. Label the thing being damaged near Hannibal, then write the baffled question across the bottom picture.
The two labels should explain the action without a separate paragraph. If the joke is about your own habits, name the habit rather than relying on “me” alone.
Original captions to try with this template.
Staying awake is treated as unrelated to the next morning’s exhaustion.
The purchase and its effect appear together before the puzzled question.
The complaint ignores the growing pile of open tabs.
References for this template. Example captions are original.
Identifies the episode, original question, and April 2018 spread of labeled screenshots.
An April 19, 2018 report describes the sketch and the emerging two-picture format.