Supermeme.ai logo
Upgrade

Desert Dilemma Meme Template

Or let AI write the Desert Dilemma meme for you

Describe your situation and get 8 caption options in seconds - free, in 110+ languages.

The format

What does Desert Dilemma mean?

Also called Water a Quarter Mile Away · Fresh Water vs. 21 Miles · Thirsty Man at Two Signs

Fresh water is only a quarter mile away, but the thirsty man crawls toward the other sign, 21 miles in the opposite direction. Fill that blank sign with the thing he wants even more.

The choice is already made: the man ignores the sensible nearby option for a much longer trip. Your caption explains the temptation strong enough to override his obvious need.

The joke works when the destination is desirable but not remotely worth the effort. A small treat or hobby can become an absurd priority.

Origin

An old cartoon gets a new destination.

The cartoon was circulating online by September 20, 2006, when a Blogspot post shared it alongside a second version. Its original illustrator is not confirmed. Early copies carry website watermarks, which identify hosts rather than establish authorship. [1]

Later versions changed the left-hand destination. Know Your Meme documents a 2015 edit and a run of Tumblr variations in late 2016 and early 2017, as the two signs became a reusable joke about misplaced priorities. [1]

How the meme spread

  1. An early repost is documented

    A blog shares the cartoon and a related variation. [1]

  2. The distant destination is replaced

    A documented edit changes what the man is crawling toward. [1]

  3. Tumblr variations spread

    New sign captions turn the cartoon into a recurring choice format. [1]

Caption guide

Put the irresistible distraction on the blank sign.

Add your destination to the large sign on the left. Keep the 21-mile arrow and the existing fresh-water sign visible.

Use a few words: the sign is a narrow area, and the distance is part of the punchline. The man’s direction already tells the reader which option he chose.

The distant temptation
Inside the blank left sign, above the 21-mile arrow.
  • Only the left destination needs a caption.
  • Keep both distances readable.
  • Choose something tempting but unnecessary.
  • Leave the man and his trail visible.

Desert Dilemma examples

Original captions to try with this template.

Make your own

Desert Dilemma: The distant temptation: Free pizzaFreepizza
Food

A detour for a free slice

The prospect of free food outweighs the much more sensible nearby water.

Read caption text
The distant temptation
Free pizza
Desert Dilemma: The distant temptation: Book saleBooksale
Hobbies

A reader with clear priorities

A bargain book becomes a destination worth an absurdly long crawl.

Read caption text
The distant temptation
Book sale
Desert Dilemma: The distant temptation: Rare lootRareloot
Gaming

The optional reward wins

The character ignores the immediate need in favor of an optional reward.

Read caption text
The distant temptation
Rare loot
Sources1 reference

References for this template. Example captions are original.

  1. Desert Dilemma: Know Your Meme

    Documents the early cartoon repost and later sign edits while noting that the illustrator is unknown.